My cousin put this song on a mix tape for me back in 2001, but accidentally cut the track off right after he sings 'I wish'. My dad, Sean and I all fell in love with this song from the first listen, and we went a little crazy wondering what exactly he wished and how the song ended. We had to special order the cd from the record shop (different days), and while we waited for it to come in, we listened to the tape over and over and tried to figure it out. Eventually the cd came in and we got to listen to the whole song.
The lyric is: 'I wish she belonged to me'. Perfect.